The Senate on Thursday, in a 62-33 vote, passed a bipartisan permitting reform bill that aims to speed up the construction of major energy infrastructure like clean energy, transmission lines, and gas pipelines.
Passage of the Bipartisan Affordability and American Jobs Act was far from guaranteed. It took years of negotiations and caused a split within the climate movement, exposing fractures among green groups. Both clean and fossil fuel energy developers, among other business groups, were immediately on board. But four key senators also had to make changes in recent weeks to address concerns from Tribes, investor-owned utilities, and environmentalists in order to win more votes.
Those changes were enough to sway the utility industry’s lobbying group, The Edison Electric Institute, and the climate advocacy group Evergreen Action. But nearly every Democratic member of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee ultimately voted against it on Thursday, excluding Rhode Island Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, a lead negotiator of the deal. Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.) also voted no, in part over provisions narrowing Tribes’ consultation rights with the federal government over cultural and sacred sites.
The bill now heads the House, where a coalition of more than 100 moderate Democrats are warming to it. Some other members, including Reps. Jared Huffman (Calif.) and Rashida Tlaib (Mich.), are opposed and argue the party should hold out until next year when it controls Congress.
Supporters of BAAJA said this is their best shot at passing permitting reform, given President Donald Trump still has two years left in office and would likely veto a version pushed by Democrats. They also argue that enacting permitting reform is a way to deliver results as soon as possible for U.S. voters demanding that politicians make their lives more affordable and make data centers pay for their energy costs.
“We cannot keep holding out on permitting reform year after year, in the hopes that maybe, just maybe, we’re going to do it a little bit better next time,” Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) said during floor debate. “This is our best option, not only for now, but likely for years to come.”
Building faster
There’s widespread agreement that it takes far too long to build energy projects in the U.S. The skyrocketing power demands of data centers, reshored manufacturing, and greater electrification of transportation and other industries has added new urgency to permitting reform. Utilities also need to continue upgrading the existing grid so it’s more resilient to extreme weather as global temperatures rise, primarily from burning fossil fuels.
BAAJA would set faster timelines for federal agencies to review and approve environmental permits for a long list of energy projects, as well as shorten the window parties have to sue from years to 150 days. The bill would also make it harder for courts to block projects under the National Environmental Policy Act, Clean Water Act, and Endangered Species Act. For example, construction could continue even if a court rules that a federal environmental review was deficient. Another section narrows the authority that states and Tribes have to deny projects over water pollution.
Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.), another lead negotiator, said that advocacy groups have historically relied on litigation to stop “bad” projects, but that the existing permitting system slows down “good” projects too. That needs to change, especially given how much clean energy is stuck in congested grid queues.
Heinrich and Whitehouse, both longtime climate hawks, are betting that clean energy will win out over polluting fossil fuels because solar, wind, and storage are quicker to build and cheaper to operate — limiting the rise of greenhouse gas emissions and energy prices.
A forecast by the Rhodium Group supports their position, showing that BAAJA will accelerate long-haul transmission lines and therefore unlock a lot more clean energy. This could reduce the power sector’s emissions by between 1% and 18% by 2040 — mainly depending on clean energy’s price competitiveness with gas — even as LNG exports rise. Average annual household electricity bills would be $50 to $78 lower by the same year, the study found, compared to business as usual.
The emissions impact of behind-the-meter gas plants at data centers isn’t included in the forecast. But Rhodium Group said those plants are generally fueled by lateral gas pipelines that typically don’t cross state boundaries or need federal permits, meaning they wouldn’t be impacted much by provisions in BAAJA.
To help expedite transmission lines, the bill would give the federal government greater authority to approve projects when states block or delay them, as well as conduct oversight of utilities’ plans. State regulators could also refer a utility to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for an investigation if they suspect local transmission planning is inefficient and overly costly to ratepayers.
An initial version of BAAJA would have eliminated utilities’ federal right of first refusal to upgrade existing lines and build new regional ones in their service territories, likely opening them up to greater competition from independent developers. However, those provisions were softened in the final bill, effectively retaining utilities’ right to replace aging corridors.
The Trump wild card
As part of the BAAJA compromise, senators also aim to lift Trump’s blockade of federal on solar and wind projects on federal lands and waters. So-called “permit certainty” provisions would ban any administration from vacating already issued permits, except under emergency scenarios — such as new information showing that a project harms national security, the environment, or human health — or in accordance with new laws or regulations.
The bill would allow any energy developer to sue federal agencies for “disparate treatment,” and outline criteria for proving it. The approach uses a 10-year lookback period to compare whether there’s a new pattern of delays or denials by an administration. Plaintiffs who win their case could collect between 50% and 100% of expected construction costs, “reasonable” litigation costs, and economic damages. Taxpayers would cover them under the federal government’s Judgement Fund.
The provisions are designed to deter future presidents from targeting specific energy technologies, as Trump is doing to renewables and former President Joe Biden did to oil and gas infrastructure.
Whitehouse has said he has assurances from administration officials that BAAJA’s “permit certainty” provisions would apply to a backlog of hundreds of clean energy projects across the Department of Interior and Pentagon, even as Trump has told reporters that he still won’t approve wind turbines.
Trump last week did endorse the bill on Truth Social, stating that it would ensure the U.S. can quickly build pipelines, mines, and power plants and lower energy costs for Americans.
The White House demanded that its ratepayer protection pledge be included in BAAJA as well. A version of it is in the bill, which would effectively double charge data centers — both for the new transmission lines needed to serve them and the cost of using the existing grid. Implementing that will be up to FERC.


